Data Protection by Design: Part 3 – Data Protection Impact Assessments
Getting your DPIA process on track
Deciding when to carry out a Data Protection Impact Assessment (DPIA), and understanding how to conduct one effectively, is a challenging area.
I’ve come across cases where DPIAs are not being conducted when necessary, or left incomplete. Less frequently, DPIAs are over-used, creating an unnecessary burden on key teams.
DPIAs sit at the heart of Data Protection by Design, and this is part 3 of our series, following on from:
Just to be clear – we may be hearing the term DPIA more frequently, but it’s not a new idea – what changed under GDPR is they were made mandatory in certain circumstances. And even if not mandatory they can be a very useful tool in your data protection toolbox.
So how do you make sure your DPIA process is on track? I’ve taken a look at the key stages you should have in place, and how to get people on-board and improve their understanding.
But first things first.
What is a Data Protection Impact Assessment?
Just to recap, a DPIA is a management tool which helps you:
- Identify privacy risks
- Assess these risks
- Adopt measures to minimise or eliminate risks
It’s a way for you to analyse your processing activities and consider any risks they might pose. It focuses on identifying any risks to people’s rights and freedoms, and considers the principles laid down in data protection law.
The key is to start the assessment process early so you can make sure any problems are found (and hopefully fixed) as soon as possible in any project – be this implementing a new system, designing a new app or creating new processes.
When is a DPIA mandatory?
When considering new systems, technologies or processes a DPIA should be conducted if these might result in a high risk to the rights and freedoms of individuals. A DPIA may also be conducted retrospectively if you believe there are inherent risks.
It’s mandatory, under the GDPR to conduct a DPIA in all of the following scenarios:
- A systematic and extensive evaluation of personal aspects relating to natural persons which is based on automated processing, including profiling, and on which decisions are based that produce legal effects concerning the natural person or similarly significantly affect the natural person
- processing on a large scale of special categories of data or of personal data relating to criminal convictions and offences
- a systematic monitoring of a publicly accessible area on a large scale
Each EU regulatory authority has published their own list of other scenarios in which a DPIA would be mandatory. You can find the UK Innformation Commissioner’s Office’s in its DPIA Guidance. This includes;
- use innovative technology (note the criteria from the European guidelines)
- process biometric data or genetic data (note the criteria from the European guidelines)
- match data or combine datasets from different sources
- collect personal data from a source other than the individual without providing them with a privacy notice (‘invisible processing’) (note the criteria from the European guidelines)
- track individuals’ location or behaviour (note the criteria from the European guidelines)
- profile children or target marketing or online services at them – it’s also worth checking the new ‘Children’s Code’ aimed at protecting children online
When a DPIA is not mandatory… but a good idea
The ICO says it’s “good practice to do a DPIA for any other major project which requires the processing of personal data.” Here are some examples of where it might be advisable to conduct a DPIA, if your processing;
- would prevent or restrict individuals from exercising their rights
- means disclosing personal data to other organisations
- is for a new purpose (i.e. not the purpose the data was originally collected for)
- will lead to transfer of personal data outside the European Economic Area (EEA)
- involves contacting individuals in a manner which could be deemed intrusive.
What the ICO expects you to do
The ICO DPIA guidance has a handy checklist of areas to focus on:
- provide training so staff understand the need to consider a DPIA at the early stages of any plan involving personal data
- make sure existing policies, processes and procedures include references to DPIA requirements
- understand the types of processing that require a DPIA, and use the screening checklist to identify the need for a DPIA, where necessary
- create and document a DPIA process
- provide training for relevant staff on how to carry out a DPIA
How to build a robust DPIA process
So how do you go about fulfilling the ICO’s expectations above? Here are some steps to take.
A. Getting Board / Senior Management buy-in
Growing awareness and buy-in from across the organisation is crucial. It can be helpful to highlight why DPIAs are a good thing, for example;
- they’re a warning system – they alert compliance teams, and the business as a whole, of risks before they occur. Prevention is always better than cure
- by identifying risks before they’ve an adverse impact, DPIAs can protect you against potential damage to your brand reputation, e.g. from complaints or enforcement action
- they help management make informed decisions about how your processing will affect the privacy of individuals
- they show you take data protection seriously and provide evidence, should you need it, of your compliance
Training is also important, I’ll come on to this in a bit, but first you need to make sure your process is fit for purpose….
B. Creating a screening questionnaire
Create a quick set of questions for business owners or project leads to use, which help to identify if a DPIA is required or not.
These can ask about the type of personal data being used, whether it entails any special category data or children’s data, what the aim of the project is and so on.
The answers can be assessed to judge whether a more detailed assessment is really required or not. (It can also show where more training might be needed, if people struggle to answer the questions).
C. The DPIA itself
You need to develop a robust process for conducting a DPIA. The ICO has a template you can use, but it’s good idea to adapt this to suit your business. Make sure it’s easy to understand and not full of data protection jargon.
These are the core aspects it needs to cover:
- describe the processing you are planning to do – it’s nature, scope, context and purposes
- assess its necessity and proportionality
- identify and asses any risks
- identify solutions and integrate into a plan
- sign off and record outcomes
- implement risk control plans
- and finally, keep your DPIA under review
Let’s look at these seven key stages in a little more depth…
1. Describe your processing
These are some of the type of questions you’d want answers to (this is not an exhaustive list):
- how is personal data being collected/used/stored and how long it is retained for?
- what are the source(s) of the personal data?
- what is the relationship with individuals whose data will be processed?
- what types of personal data does it involve, does this include special category data, children’s data or other vulnerable groups?
- what is the scale of the activity – how many individuals will be affected?
- is the processing within individuals’ reasonable expectations?
- will data be transferred to a third party and is this third party based outside the EEA?
- what risks have already been identified?
- what are the objectives? Why is it important to the business and / or beneficial for individuals?
2. Necessity and proportionality
Consider the following questions (again, this is not an exhaustive list):
- what is the most appropriate lawful basis for processing?
- is there another way to achieve the same outcome?
- have you ensured that the minimum amount of personal data is used to achieve your objectives (i.e. data minimisation)?
- how can you ensure data quality and integrity is maintained?
- how will you inform individuals about any new processing?
- how will individuals’ rights be upheld?
- are any processors used and if so how will you ensure their compliance?
- how will international transfers be protected, what safeguard mechanisms will be used?
- who will have access to personal data, does this need to be restricted?
- where will data be stored and how will it be kept secure?
- how long will data be retained and how will data be destroyed when no longer required?
- have the relevant staff received appropriate data protection training?
3. Identify and assess the risks
Identify any privacy issues with the project and associated risks. These may be risks to the individuals whose data is being processed, compliance or commercial risks.
Is there potential for harm, whether this be physical, material or non-material? A DPIA should ideally benchmark the level of risk using a risk matrix which considers both the likelihood and the severity of any impact on individuals.
You don’t have to eliminate all risks, but they should be documented, and any residual risks need to be understood and, if appropriate, accepted by the business.
If you identify a high risk that you cannot mitigate, you must consult the ICO before starting the processing.
4. Identify solutions and integrate into a plan
Develop solutions which will eliminate or minimise privacy risks and then consider how these solutions impact on the project.
It can be helpful to use the established ‘four strategies for risk management’ (the 4Ts), i.e.
- Treat the risk, i.e. adopt measures to minimise or eliminate risk
- Transfer the risk, e.g. outsource the processing
- Tolerate, e.g. accept risk if its within the organisations accepted level of risk
- Terminate it, i.e. stop that specific processing or change the process in such a way that the risk no longer exists
5. Sign off and record outcomes
Someone must sign-off that the DPIA is complete and be accountable for any residual risks. It’s a good idea to log residual risks in your Risk Register.
6. Implement risk control plans
7. And finally, keep your DPIA under review
There’s also lots of useful content on this in the ICO’s DPIA Guidance.
D. Awareness and Training
Once you have your questionnaire and DPIA process ready to go, it’s time to make sure people know about it! If people aren’t aware they’ll be busy doing fabulously innovative things, not considering the potential data protection issues and impact on people’s privacy.
Making sure your teams know what a DPIA is, in simple layman’s terms, is an important step – building an understanding about why it’s important and the benefits to the business as a whole.
Creating short, easy to understand, guidelines and raising awareness via other means helps reinforce the message that DPIAs are a good thing and people need to think data protection in their day to day work.
It’s also important to develop people’s skills. After all the DPO (or team/person responsible for data protection) can’t do this single-handed. You need key people to know;
- what a DPIA entails
- how to answer the questions
- what are the types of risks to look out for
- what type of solutions will mitigate any identified risks
Holding workshops with relevant staff to discuss how you conduct a DPIA, and / or perhaps run through an example, can help improve people’s skills. My key tip would be to try and not over-complicate things and to keep it straightforward.
In summary, whether you are required by law or not to complete a DPIA they are a useful way to make sure data protection is considered from the outset, with no nasty surprises just before your project launches!
“But it’s essential that we go live on Friday!” If I had a penny for every time I’ve heard this one. If only they’d known, or thought of, speaking to the people responsible for data protection.
Often a DPIA won’t required, but there’ll be times when it’s mandatory or just a very good idea.
Data Protection team over-stretched? We can review your existing DPIA process or help you to develop one. We can also do remote DPIA workshops for key members of your teams – Get in touch