GDPR: Consent and why records are crucial
The ICO has fined a telemarketing firm £90k for their inability to demonstrate valid and specific consent was collected from the people they’d contacted. Data was collected directly, via the telemarketer’s website and via a third-party survey company.
Crucially, the firm couldn’t produce evidence of consent. This led me to think about other organisations; you may have gone to great efforts to make sure the consent you collect meets the GDPR standard, but are you keeping adequate records? Occasionally, the old legal adage applies – ‘If it isn’t written down, it didn’t happen.’
If your consent is subject to regulatory scrutiny, proof is highly likely to be requested. A customer might ask for evidence, and could escalate a complaint if you’re unable to produce it.
So, what records do we need to keep?
Here’s a refresher on the consent rules and how to retain adequate evidence. For simplicity’s sake when I refer to GDPR in this article I mean both GDPRs – the EU and UK flavours.
Consent is ONE of SIX lawful bases for processing
Consent is just one of six lawful bases. GDPR requires organisations to select an appropriate lawful basis for each purpose for processing personal data. They’re all equally valid; no single basis is better than another. You should choose the most appropriate basis for each activity. Often consent might not be appropriate, but sometimes consent is required by law for certain activities.
Just be mindful; don’t rely on consent if another lawful basis would be more appropriate. But also be careful not to try and shoe-horn your activities into another lawful basis (such as legitimate interests), when consent really would be the best approach, or is legally required.
What constitutes valid consent
GDPR defines consent as “any freely given, specific, informed and unambiguous indication of the data subject’s wishes by which he or she, by a statement or by a clear affirmative action, signifies agreement to the processing of personal data relating to him or her”.
Let’s break this down…
Freely given consent
■ People must be given a genuine choice
■ People should be able to refuse to give their consent without detriment
■ Consent should be easy to withdraw
■ Consent shouldn’t be bundled into T&Cs, unless necessary for the service
It’s also sometimes important to weigh up any ‘imbalance of power’ over the individual whose consent you seek. For example, consent may not be freely given if the individual feels they don’t really have a choice. Consent can therefore be tricky in employer-employee relationships, if staff might feel a degree of pressure, or feel they will be penalised or treated differently if they refuse.
Specific and informed consent
■ It must be clear who people are giving their consent to. The organisation relying on the consent must be clearly identified. If you want to rely on consent collected for you by a third party, your organisations must be named at the time consent is collected.
■ Consent must specifically cover all of the purposes for which it’s being collected. Separate consent should be collected, wherever possible, for different activities. For example, collecting separate marketing consents for different marketing channels. This isn’t a hard and fast rule and isn’t required if it would be unduly disruptive, or the activities are clearly interdependent.
■ It must be clear people can withdraw their consent at any time (and the ICO advises you include details of how to do so).
Remember, there’s specific information you’ll always need to provide when you collect people’s personal details. There are distinct transparency requirements and people have the right to be informed. You may choose to take a layered approach, and it’s advisable to always have a clear link to a Privacy Notice (aka Privacy Policy), or details of how to access this.
Consent by an unambiguous indication and clear affirmative action
Consent must be given by a deliberate and specific action to opt-in or agree. For example; an opt-in box, clicking ‘submit, signing a statement, or verbal confirmation. Failing to opt-out is not consent. Pre-ticked boxes are not consent.
For more information see ICO consent guidance, which covers how to collect consent, how to manage requests to withdraw, and more.
Evidence of consent
GDPR states: “Where processing is based on consent, the controller shall be able to demonstrate that the data subject has consented to processing of his or her personal data.”
This means, organisations must have an audit trail to meet their accountability obligations. This is what the telemarketing firm failed to grasp. In practice, this means keeping records of:
■ Who consented e.g. their name or other identifier.
■ When they consented e.g. an online time stamped record, a copy of a dated document or a note of the time and date verbal consent was given.
■ What they were told at the time e.g. a copy of the consent statement used at the time, along any separate privacy notice or other privacy information used at the time.
■ How consent was given e.g. a copy of the data capture form or a note of a verbal conversation.
■ Any withdrawal of consent, and when.
This is why we recommend when your updating consent statements or privacy notice(s) keeping copies of older notices and the dates they were operative. This doesn’t need to extend to keeping copies of every web form, but records held on your CRM or other relevant system need to be accurate. The ICO guidance on keeping records of consent is a useful resource.
Consent isn’t easy
Collecting valid consent can feel like a minefield. It means carefully ticking off requirements and keeping evidence. This isn’t hard once you’ve established a routine and get into the habit of thinking ‘that needs keeping hold of.’ Getting this right, means you’ll breathe a sigh of relief if you’re ever subjected to scrutiny.
For more detail on when consent is legally required under UK ePrivacy law for marketing activities see our guides to the email marketing rules and telemarketing rules.